As depicted in the supplied chart, headline inflation in Canada (red
dotted line) is now at the midpoint of the Bank of Canada’s target
range (grey shaded area of 1 – 3%). Notice headline inflation is now
well below the Bank of Canada’s overnight policy rate of 4.25% (solid
blue line). Recall, the Bank of Canada has recently reduced short-term
interest rates by 0.75% with three separate 0.25% cuts since June.
What is most interesting and less obvious from the chart is current
Canadian interest rates are the most restrictive they’ve been since
2006. Whether interest rates are restrictive or accommodative is
determined by the Bank of Canada’s policy rate being above or below
the rate of inflation (blue line is above or below red line). When the
Bank of Canada raises interest rates above the rate of inflation, they
are doing so to reduce inflation and slow the economy. Conversely,
when the Bank of Canada reduces interest rates below the rate of
inflation, they are doing so to stimulate the economy and potentially
increase inflation if it has fallen below 1% which is the lower end of
their inflation mandate.
With inflation now within the Bank of Canada’s target range and the
economy slowing, the Bank of Canada is reducing interest rates to
bring them back towards a neutral rate (neither accommodative nor
restrictive). The National Bank economic team’s estimate for the
current neutral rate in Canada is 2.5 – 3%. This means the Bank of
Canda needs to reduce interest rates by another 1.25 – 1.75% just to
get to a point where rates are no longer restrictive. Given rates will
remain restrictive for the near-term, the Canadian economy is expected
to continue to slow.
Monetary policy (central banks adjusting interest rates and money
supply to control inflation) has a delayed impact on the economy. The
economic impact of increasing interest rates was delayed by 18-24
months and the impact of reducing rates, which only began in June, is
likely to have a similarly lagged impact. In other words, the Canadian
economy is expected to continue to slow well into next year with the
impact of lower interest rates not being felt until late 2025 or early
2026. What we won’t know until after the fact is if the Bank of Canada
reduced interest rates quickly enough to avoid a recession. With
inflation now seemingly under control, I would expect voices calling
for the Bank of Canada to cut rates more aggressively to grow louder
in coming months.